Back
Back
5 November 2026

Advance Payment vs Earnest-Money Deposit: Buying Property in Russia

Two participants' hands reviewing a blank cream document and envelope at a modern office counter

An advance payment and an earnest-money deposit differ in purpose and in the consequences of non-performance. An advance is a prepayment, while an earnest-money deposit also confirms a contract and secures its performance. Russian law requires a written agreement for an earnest-money deposit. Forfeiture or payment of twice the amount depends on responsibility and the conditions of Article 381 of the Russian Civil Code, not simply on the purchase falling through.

Before transferring money for a property, establish which obligation is being paid or secured, who receives the money and what happens if circumstances change. Neither the label reservation nor a promise to return everything explains this. This guide concerns property purchases in Russia, including commercial offices. Earnest-money deposit refers here to the Russian legal concept of zadatok, not a foreign escrow or exchange arrangement.

The other transaction terms are covered in the guide to the sale and purchase agreement for non-residential premises. Here, the focus is the preliminary payment, its documentation and possible repayment scenarios.

Advance payment and earnest-money deposit: the key differences

Both amounts can be taken into account when settling the purchase price, but their legal purposes differ. Compare the entire arrangement, not just the label. The table outlines the general principles rather than determining the outcome of a particular transaction.

Prepayment and security for an obligation
Question Advance payment Earnest money (zadatok)
Purpose Payment in advance Part of the payments due, evidence of the contract and security for performance
Specific form requirement Check the form of the relevant contract and payment documents Written agreement regardless of the amount
Purchase goes ahead Accounted for in the payments on the agreed terms Accounted for in the amounts due, with regard to the secured obligation
Purchase does not go ahead Review the basis for repayment and any other lawful claims Check the grounds for return, forfeiture or twice the amount under Article 381
Can it be described as risk-free? No. An advance does not remove obligations or liability No. Security does not guarantee performance or actual recovery of money

The main mistake is to choose between a supposedly safe advance and a supposedly non-refundable deposit. Russian law does not create that simple choice. Match the agreed obligations to the consequences that the parties are prepared to accept.

What an advance payment means in a property purchase

In this context, an advance means paying before the seller's agreed performance. Its payment function alone does not create the special consequences of an earnest-money deposit. That does not mean the contract is non-binding or the buyer can withdraw at any time without consequences.

Where a sale contract provides for prepayment, the applicable contract and statutory rules govern it. For example, Article 487 of the Russian Civil Code addresses a seller who receives prepayment but does not deliver the paid-for property within the agreed period: the buyer may demand delivery or repayment. This particular mechanism should not be turned into a universal rule for every amount transferred during negotiations.

When the relationship ends, establish whether a legal basis for retaining the money remains, whether anything has been performed and whether there are counterclaims or other agreed terms. Retention is not lawful merely because the recipient mentions expenses. Equally, the absence of a security function does not exclude a separately established contractual penalty or other claims. The documents and circumstances determine the result, not a single word.

What an earnest-money deposit secures

Article 380 of the Russian Civil Code links an earnest-money deposit to particular contractual payments and security for performance. First identify the obligation being secured. It may concern performance of the main contract or, unless the law provides otherwise, the obligation to enter into it on the terms of a preliminary agreement.

Ask a direct question: what must each party do after the money is received? Provide documents, enter into a contract within an agreed period, pay the balance or perform another specified obligation? The provisions should be consistent. A deposit does not supply a list of duties that the parties have failed to agree.

If the purchase proceeds as agreed, clearly account for the amount already paid. If the obligation is not performed, responsibility must be established before applying Article 381. The word deposit in a document does not determine in advance who will be responsible for every possible future event.

Check the written terms before transferring money

An earnest-money deposit agreement must be in writing regardless of its amount. Where there is doubt about whether a payment is an earnest-money deposit, Article 380 treats it as an advance unless otherwise proved. Failure to comply with the written form is expressly identified as one possible reason for such doubt.

This does not mean legal classification depends solely on the heading of a standalone document. The agreement, related documents and relationship are assessed together. A payment order confirms a transfer but may not explain all the obligations. A receipt cannot be assessed without reading it either: what matters is which arrangements it actually records.

  • Parties and recipient: who pays whom, and on what basis.
  • Property and obligation: which asset and contract the amount relates to.
  • Purpose: prepayment or an earnest-money deposit providing security.
  • Amount and accounting: how the money is transferred and credited towards the price.
  • Next steps: deadlines, documents and the parties' interaction.
  • Changed circumstances: grounds for ending the arrangement and settling the payments afterwards.
  • Evidence: how receipt of money, notices and performance are documented.

This is a list of questions, not a ready-to-sign agreement. The required documents and their form depend on the transaction. Avoid filling in a random template while leaving conflicting payment, main-contract and preliminary provisions unresolved.

Can a deposit be paid before the main contract?

Yes. Article 380(4) of the Russian Civil Code permits an earnest-money deposit to secure the obligation to enter into the main contract on the terms of a preliminary agreement, unless the law provides otherwise. The statement that only an advance is possible before the main contract is signed is too categorical.

A preliminary agreement under Article 429 governs the future obligation to enter into the main contract. Its form is linked to the form required for that contract, and its content must identify the subject matter and relevant agreed terms. A preliminary arrangement and a payment do not themselves transfer ownership of the office.

Review the substance, not just the description of an agreement as preliminary. In Resolution 49 of 25 December 2018, the Russian Supreme Court explained that the name does not rule out a different legal classification. In particular, an agreement for a future asset requiring payment of the price or a substantial part in advance may be classified as a sale with prepayment. Applying that guidance to a particular document requires legal assessment.

When is the deposit returned, retained or doubled?

Instead of asking only who withdrew first, work through the sequence: what was secured, which obligation was not performed, why and who is responsible. A cancelled meeting, the end of negotiations and contractual non-performance are not interchangeable descriptions.

  1. The purchase proceeds. Account for the sum in the agreed payments and make sure it is not included in the balance a second time.
  2. The obligation ends by mutual agreement before performance begins. Article 381(1) provides for return. Record the agreement and the subsequent payment arrangements.
  3. The obligation ends before performance begins because performance is impossible under Article 416 of the Russian Civil Code. Article 381 also provides for return, but an ordinary practical difficulty cannot automatically be treated as that legal ground.
  4. The party who paid the deposit is responsible for non-performance. Under Article 381(2), the other party retains it when the conditions for that rule are met.
  5. The recipient is responsible for non-performance. Article 381 provides for payment of twice the deposit amount in total. It is not return of the original sum plus two further amounts.

The law also addresses damages with the deposit taken into account, unless the contract provides otherwise. The calculation may therefore involve more than one line. In a dispute, do not treat every delay as sufficient grounds for retention or double payment without reviewing the agreement.

If financing is refused or documents need checking

If the purchase depends on financing, discuss that dependency before paying. A bank's refusal does not produce a universal answer about the deposit. The agreed duties, allocation of financing risk, termination provisions and circumstances of the refusal need to be examined.

Article 416 links impossibility of performance to its statutory conditions. A funding shortfall, new management plans or a more attractive property should not automatically be described as such impossibility. A company buying an office should align its internal decisions and payment arrangements before accepting obligations.

Separately establish which property information must be confirmed before the next step, who supplies the documents and when, and what the parties do if discrepancies emerge. For initial ownership checks, see the guide to an EGRN extract. A repayment clause does not replace investigation of the property or resolve contradictions already present in the documents.

Identify the recipient and document the payment

The recipient matters as much as the payment reference. Money paid to the seller towards the price and a fee paid to an intermediary for a separate service may have different legal bases. Not every payment requested alongside an office purchase forms part of its price.

Before transferring, reconcile the recipient with the contract and check the representative's authority and the agreed bank details. Where companies are involved, identify the contracting entity and authorised signatory correctly. The explanation that it is more convenient for accounting does not establish why a particular recipient may accept payment under that obligation.

The payment reference should identify the relevant document and the agreed purpose accurately, without accidentally describing a different arrangement. Keep the transfer confirmation, signed documents, any receipt and material correspondence. They answer different questions: whether money was paid, on what basis and what the parties subsequently did.

If the buyer, seller, property or payment structure changes, agree what happens to the sum already transferred. Do not assume it automatically moves to a new transaction because discussions continue. The changes should be understood by everyone concerned and recorded in the appropriate documents.

A deposit, pledge and security payment are not the same

These words are sometimes used interchangeably in conversation. However, a pledge under Article 334 of the Russian Civil Code gives preferential satisfaction of a secured claim from the value of pledged property when the relevant grounds exist. That is a different mechanism from paying an earnest-money deposit towards contractual payments.

A security payment under Article 381.1 can secure a monetary obligation, including a future one. It is applied when the contractual circumstances arise, while repayment follows its own rules and contractual qualifications. The double-payment mechanism for an earnest-money deposit cannot simply be applied to it.

Labels such as deposit, guarantee contribution and non-refundable reservation fee do not replace legal analysis. Establish whether the money pays for property, secures an obligation, pays for a separate service or relates to another agreed arrangement. Assessing whether retention is lawful starts with the relationship's substance, not a confident label in a message.

Choosing a payment arrangement before the purchase

Start with the stage of preparation, not the amount most often seen in advertisements. If key documents or financing are still unconfirmed, agree how those dependencies will be handled first. Where duties are already defined, the parties can discuss security and the consequences of non-performance.

Ask what is confirmed now, what remains to be checked, what action follows payment, what constitutes performance and how the end of the arrangement is recorded. The explanation that money is needed to remove an advertisement does not describe the entire future contract.

The amount, timing, credit towards the price and acceptable risk are agreed for the particular transaction. The general provisions considered here do not establish one mandatory percentage for every property purchase. Do not choose a deposit solely for the prospect of double payment, or an advance solely because you expect it to be easily recoverable in every case. Realistic obligations and clear consequences matter to both parties.

A hypothetical example: a company preparing to buy an office

Suppose a company has selected an office but has not yet reached its final financing decision. The seller requests a reservation payment, while the draft document calls it both an advance and an earnest-money deposit. It is unclear who receives the money and what happens if the property documents do not confirm the initial information.

The sensible next step is to resolve the inconsistencies before paying. The parties identify the payment's purpose, recipient, linked obligation, subsequent documents and actions if the agreed circumstances change. A lawyer checks that the wording fits the chosen legal arrangement. The transfer confirmation should then be consistent with those terms.

If documents have already been signed and money paid, the task changes: reconstruct what was agreed, what has been performed and what grounds exist for any claims. Simply renaming the payment afterwards does not resolve a dispute. This is a teaching example without real amounts, not a statement of F-375's sale terms or a prediction of a court's decision.

Advance payment and deposit questions

What is the difference between an advance and an earnest-money deposit?

An advance is a prepayment. An earnest-money deposit also confirms a contract and secures performance. It requires a written agreement, and the special consequences of non-performance follow Article 381 of the Russian Civil Code with regard to the parties' responsibility.

Is an advance always returned if the property is not purchased?

There is no universal answer. An advance does not automatically have the consequences of an earnest-money deposit, but repayment depends on its legal basis, the contract, performance and other lawful claims. Unconditional immediate repayment cannot be promised for every reason the relationship ends.

When must the seller pay twice the deposit?

If the amount is legally an earnest-money deposit and its recipient is responsible for non-performance of the secured contract, Article 381(2) applies. Double payment does not follow every cancellation. It means twice the amount in total, not three times, and does not guarantee voluntary payment.

Can an earnest-money deposit secure a preliminary agreement?

Yes. Article 380(4) of the Russian Civil Code permits it to secure the obligation to enter into the main contract on the terms of a preliminary agreement, unless the law provides otherwise. Check the content, form and timing of the arrangements.

Is writing earnest-money deposit in the payment reference enough?

The label alone does not determine the payment's legal nature. Russian law requires a written earnest-money deposit agreement. Its substance and related documents are assessed; a payment order primarily confirms the transfer and its stated purpose.

Will the deposit be returned if the bank refuses financing?

A refusal alone does not produce the same outcome in every case. Review the obligation, financing and termination terms, responsibility and circumstances. These dependencies are best agreed before money changes hands.

Are an earnest-money deposit, pledge and security payment the same?

No. They are different legal mechanisms. Articles 380 and 381 govern an earnest-money deposit, Article 381.1 has separate rules for a security payment, and a pledge concerns satisfaction of a claim from pledged property under the applicable provisions.

Is there a mandatory deposit amount for buying an office?

The general provisions considered here do not set one percentage for all office purchases. The amount and terms are agreed with regard to the obligation and applicable law. An advertisement or one participant's usual practice does not create a universal rule.

What to agree before buying an office

Before transferring, understand more than the amount: establish the payment's basis, recipient, treatment in the purchase price, subsequent duties and possible return. Put the agreed terms into consistent documents. If the legal purpose or consequences remain unclear, review them with a lawyer before paying rather than after a disagreement arises.

Explore the office penthouse for sale in Moscow City and request viewing materials on the F-375 website. F-375 does not offer legal services. This guide does not establish reservation, preliminary payment or settlement terms for any particular property.